In the spirit of Valentine’s Day, our topic for this month is “I Love You” Wills – a Will that leaves everything you own to your spouse outright at your death. This is the most basic form of Will — one that many couples create when they are young and never consider changing. On its face, it appears that there would be nothing wrong with such a simple Will. However, “I Love You” Wills are not appropriate for all couples, and in many cases deprive your spouse and family of the benefits a more sophisticated estate plan can provide.
Here are reasons why your “I Love You” Will may not be the right match for you:
- Estate Tax Savings. If you leave all of your assets to your spouse at death, there will be no federal or Massachusetts estate tax payable because of the unlimited estate tax marital deduction available both federally and in Massachusetts. However, upon the surviving spouse’s death, all of the assets will be subject to estate tax. An estate tax will be payable to the Commonwealth if the value of those assets exceeds $1 million. If, instead of leaving all of your assets to your spouse, you left your assets to a properly drafted Trust for your spouse’s benefit, you could shelter up to $1 million of assets from Massachusetts estate tax. For many families, this can save $100,000 or more in estate taxes that your children or heirs would otherwise have to pay at your spouse’s death.
- Long-Term Care Planning. If your “I Love You” Will leaves all of your assets to your spouse at your death, those assets (with limited exceptions) will be considered “countable” assets if your spouse requires long-term nursing home care and applies for MassHealth (Medicaid) benefits to pay for that care. A single person can have no more than $2,000 of countable assets in order to qualify for MassHealth. This means your spouse will need to spend down all of those countable assets on his or her care before being eligible for MassHealth benefits. Alternatively, you can create a Will that leaves your assets to a so-called “testamentary trust” for your spouse’s benefit. A properly drafted testamentary trust will allow the trust assets to be used for your spouse’s benefit during your spouse’s lifetime, but those trust assets will not be countable should your spouse require long-term nursing home care after your death. This not only makes qualification for MassHealth benefits easier, but means the trust assets can be used to provide items or services for your spouse that MassHealth does not provide. This may improve the quality of your spouse’s life long after you are gone.
- Asset Protection. If your spouse is not experienced at managing money, or if your spouse is among the many people who are vulnerable to spendthrift tendencies or other vices that make it hard for them to hold on to money, an “I Love You” Will is a recipe for disaster. After your death, all of the assets will be in the control of your surviving spouse and will be vulnerable to the survivor’s spending habits and their all-too-frequent trips to Foxwoods. Or perhaps your surviving spouse is just too nice for her own good and would be vulnerable to the pleas of children, grandchildren, or friends who are down on their luck to “loan” funds that are never repaid. Consider whether leaving your assets (or at least a portion of them) in trust for your spouse and naming a Trustee (a responsible family member or friend) to manage money for your spouse may be a better alternative. Your spouse may lose some degree of control, but you can rest easier knowing that assets will be there to meet your spouse’s needs, and that your spouse won’t be the victim of financial exploitation, creditors, or her own spending habits.
- Second Marriage – If you are among the lucky ones to have Cupid’s arrow hit home multiple times, an “I Love You” Will is probably inadequate to meet your needs. If you have children from your prior marriage, you may want to leave some or all of your assets to them, and your spouse may want to do the same for his or her children. In such a case, an “I Love You” Will that leaves all of your assets to your surviving spouse is not appropriate even if your spouse promises to leave the assets to your children at her death. The needs of the surviving spouse’s own children, a new spouse, financial exploitation, or long-term care needs can derail even the most sincere of promises, and leave children from a prior marriage with nothing.
- Avoiding Probate – Even if you want your surviving spouse to have full control of all of your assets at your death, an “I Love You” Will is a public, costly and time-consuming way to achieve that result. Your Will will be filed with the probate court after your death, and any assets owned by you in your individual name will be subject to a probate proceeding. This process, although effective, can take a year or more to complete and means spending money on attorneys’ fees, publication costs, filing fees, and other expenses. Passing your assets to your intended beneficiaries outside of probate will reduce the time, costs, aggravation and loss of privacy typically associated with the probate process.
If you and your spouse created “I Love You” Wills many years ago, it is definitely time to review them and probably time for a change. Love may be blind, but your estate plan should see you through all of life’s twists and turns. Talk to an experienced estate planning attorney, who can help you create a plan that’s appropriate for your family.
Attorney Maria Baler is an estate planning and elder law attorney and a partner with the Dedham law firm of Samuel, Sayward & Baler LLC. She is also a director of the Massachusetts Chapter of the National Academy of Elder Law Attorneys (MassNAELA). For more information, visit www.ssbllc.com or call (781) 461-1020. This article is not intended to provide legal advice or create or imply an attorney-client relationship. No information contained herein is a substitute for a personal consultation with an attorney.
February 2016